Thinking of Moving to Muttontown NY? [2022] | 👍 ULTIMATE Living in Muttontown Guide

Situated on Long Island within the Town of Oyster Bay lives the small yet enchanting village of Muttontown, New York. As a suburb of New York City and just over 5 miles south of the lovely Oyster Bay Habor, Muttontown is a part of Nassau County. The extremely safe and rural village of Muttontown was ranked as one of America’s wealthiest towns by Bloomberg Businessweek and is known for being home to notable places like the Muttontown County Club and the Muttontown Preserve. Along with a few highly-rated golf and country clubs, Muttontown provides its few thousand residents with several excellent preserves and nature centers as well as being just minutes away from a wide selection of tasty restaurants and state parks! Incorporated in 1931, Muttontown on Long Island was formerly used as a sheep pasturage during colonial times. More recently, Muttowntown has resident American singer-songwriter Alicia Keys, and former American football quarterback Chad Pennington. The upper-class and family-friendly village of Muttontown contains a relaxed and small-town atmosphere while still being within an hour commute time to New York City.

Muttontown, Long Island Population and Demographics

According to the U.S. Census, the incorporated village of Muttontown has a population of 3,669 which has increased by 4.9% in the last decade. The median age in Muttontown sits at 50.3 years whereas the median household income is a staggering $212,950– more than double the state average. 69% of the residents in Muttontown are married and their homes have an average of 3 people per household. On the other hand, 95.9% of the Muttontown population has earned a high school degree or higher and 70.8% have attained a bachelor’s degree or higher. The job market in Muttontown has gone up by .9% in the last year which should help the 5.9% unemployed.

Muttontown’s racial demographics are rather diverse with whites taking up 65.8% of the population and Asian at 25.2%. Behind them are Hispanics and blacks at 4.99% and 1.74%. Males make up 52% of the Muttontown population which leaves 48% for the females.

With an A+ safety score on Crimegrade, Muttontown is a very safe place to settle down and raise a family. The crime rate in Muttontown is 3.32 per 1,000 residents which is far below the national average. If you’re in need of backup, all 14 sworn officers of the Oyster Bay Police Department are at your service.

Cost of Living in Muttontown, NY

If moving to Nassau County the Economic Policy Institute recommends a family of four to be making at least $143,251 to attain a comfortable state of living. However, keep in mind that the cost of living in Muttontown, Long Island is around 140% higher than the state itself. Muttontown has a sales tax of 8.625% and an income tax of 6.5%. According to Redfin, the current median house price in Muttontown is $2.07 million which is over $1.6 million above the state median. If you’re in search of a house, you can try browning the internet for Muttontown homes for sale. If signing a lease is your plan of action, the average apartment rent in Muttontown, NY is at $3,427 on RentCafe.

Muttontown, Long Island Everyday Expenses:

The following costs are Numbeo’s expenses in the town of Oyster Bay, NY. Because the prices are not specially assigned solely to the village, they reflect but may slightly differ from the exact prices in Muttontown.

  • Basic utilities— $168.98
  • Internet— $62.86
  • Gallon of milk— $4.69
  • Carton of eggs— $2.93
  • Gas— $3.25

Muttontown, NY Neighborhoods | Where to Live in Muttontown, Long Island

The majority of Muttontown real estate is known to have sumptuous, expensive, and pristine houses. The village tends to have the most affordable houses toward the east part as well as the notable Woodside Country Club. The northwest part of Muttontown is often said to be the most appealing and provides close access to the Muttontown Country Club. On top of having the beautiful gated community of Stone Hill Muttontown, if you’re looking for the safest area to live, the south is usually considered to have the least amount of crime.

Most areas have around a 32-mile distance from Muttontown to New York City which will take you West on the road for about an hour with no traffic. If you’ve decided on moving, you can try searching online for Muttontown, NY homes for sale. No matter where you end up settling, all locations in Muttontown provide incredibly safe, welcoming, and clean communities that have good proximity to larger towns and cities.

Muttontown, NY Climate and Weather

Muttontown on Long Island experiences a temperate climate in which the summers are warm and humid with highs of 83 degrees Fahrenheit and the winters are cold and snowy with lows of 25 degrees Fahrenheit. This makes for the perfect weather for residents to spend some time at the village’s historical preserves! Muttontown receives 46 inches of rain per year whereas your shades will be put to use throughout the 174 days of sunshine. You can also utilize your winter coats during the 24 inches of snow per year in Muttontown. With summer and fall as the most comfortable seasons, the best months to visit Muttontown, NY are in June, August, and September.

Things to do in Muttontown, Long Island

Along with a few remarkable golf courses and a handful of historical and nature reserves, you’ll always have close access to the East Norwich Shopping Center while living in Muttontown. For when you’re in need of a local, authentic produce mill, the Jericho Cider Mill in Muttontown will serve you well! Take a look at some fun things to do in Muttontown, Long Island below!

Muttontown Preserve

With over 550 acres of lovely fields, ponds, woods, and historic grounds including Muttontown’s Chelsea Mansion, this preserve is the perfect place to escape into the hidden wonders of nature, wildlife, and history!

Muttontown, NY 11791, +1 516-571-8500

Big River Barn Rescue Inc.

Whether you have experience with horses or not, this horseback riding service in Muttontown provides a home for rescued and rehabilitated horses that guests can gently take for a stroll on the trail. This is the perfect place for those who enjoy horseback and have a heart for recovering animals.

1864 Muttontown Rd, Syosset, NY 11791, +1 516-650-0016

Additional Attractions in Muttontown, NY:

All preserves in Muttontown are maintained by Nassau County’s Parks, Recreation, and Museum department. If you’re looking for fun events going on in Muttontown, you can check that out here

Muttontown, Long Island Restaurants

Butera’s Restaurant of Woodbury

As a popular destination for families and groups, this family-owned Italian restaurant serves everything from tasty pasta dishes to fresh fish entrees!

7903 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury, NY 11797, +1 516-496-3633

Mara’s Southern Kitchen

This authentic barbeque restaurant serves fresh Southern and Cajun cuisine that is sure to keep you coming back!

236 W Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, NY 11791, +1 516-554-5510

Jobs in Muttontown, NY

Muttontown, Long Island mostly consists of white-collar jobs in the work field whereas the average base salary sits at $74,567 and according to Payscale, the entire Oyster Bay area has an average hourly rate of approximately $17.14. The majority of careers in Muttontown consist of healthcare, professional, scientific, and financial positions. Some of the nearby top employers include Aav and Mill-Max Mfg.

Looking for a bigger city to commute to other than New York? The distance from Muttontown to Queens is about 19 miles south. If you’re on the hunt for work, try searching for job openings in and around Muttontown, NY.

Muttontown, Long Island Schools

All top-rated schools near Muttontown are served by the Jericho Union Free School District, the Syosset Central School District, and the Locust Valley Central School District. Some of the nearby schools include Robbins Lane Elementary School and Long Island Lutheran Middle & High School.

Whether you’re a senior citizen on the hunt for a new novel or a student in search of quiet studying time, the Jericho Public Library is just minutes away!

Muttontown, NY Statistics and Information

Muttontown, NY of Nassau County has a land area of 6.058 miles squared and a population density of 605.1 people per mile. The village of Muttontown on Long Island has an elevation of 285 feet above sea level and a zip code of 11771. With the area code of 516, Muttontown is within the Eastern Time Zone. If you’re in need of air travel the nearest international airport is the John F. Kennedy International Airport which is about 25.5 miles away.

Muttontown, Long Island Map

Discover even more things to do in around Muttontown with this map below!

Pros and Cons of Living in Muttontown, NY

Pro: Enjoy decent proximity to New York City, Brooklyn, and especially Queens without sacrificing the serenity of the smaller community.
Pro: Sleep sound knowing the village is incredibly safe and secure!
Con: Keep in mind that the cost of living here is significantly above the state and national averages.

Does living in Muttontown, NY spark your interest? Zippboxx will make your relocation a breeze! Call us today at 631-600-0000 or fill out the “Request A Quote” form so our experienced Muttontown moving services can help get your stress-free transfer started!

Rob Marchese
Rob Marchese is one of the founders of Zippboxx Moving and Storage. Since the start of the company it's been Rob's mission to change the way the moving industry is perceived.  The number one goal is to make the moving and storage process as stress free as possible for each and every customer. "The way we do this is by honesty, transparency, and providing a high quality of service."
  • Request a Quote

    • MM slash DD slash YYYY
  • Popular Categories

  • Popular Tags