9 Best Gated Communities on Long Island 🔑🏘 | Private Long Island Gated Communities You’ll Love

Long Island may be known for its historic North Shore mansions and large estates, but it’s also home to a growing number of gated communities that offer a combination of safety, security, and amenities. Gated communities on Long Island range from affordable older gated condo developments and 55 and over communities to new construction communities with the latest amenities and stylish finishes. Here are nine of the most exciting Long Island gated communities you’ll want to see for yourself.

Gated Communities in Nassau County Long Island

Want to stay close to NYC while enjoying Long Island living at its best? There are many highly rated gated communities in Long Island’s Nassau County including many of the newest developments.

Gracewood at North Hills – Luxury Homes on Private 80-Acre Preserve on the North Shore

  • Housing options: Detached homes
  • Location: North Hills, Town of North Hempstead

The small village of North Hills in North Hempstead, close to Manhasset and Roslyn Heights, is home to one of the most prestigious gated communities on Long Island. Gracewood at North Hills is a private North Shore gated community of 141 detached homes on 80 acres of manicured park-like grounds. The property was formerly part of the Grace Family’s estate with the family mansion now the Gracewood Clubhouse.

Residents enjoy 24-hour security and a range of amenities including a playground, children’s playroom, fitness center, library, steam room and full men’s and women’s locker rooms, and outdoor and indoor pools.

There are seven floor plans in the community with homes built in the late 1990s. All homes have 4+ bedrooms, full basements, and fireplaces. Homes usually sell for more than $2.5 million.

Roslyn Landing – Waterfront Gated Community in Long Island Walking Distance to Dining & Shops

  • Housing options: Townhomes, flat-over-flat condos, and detached homes
  • Location: Roslyn, Town of North Hempstead

Roslyn Landing is one of the most exciting Long Island gated communities and one of the few developments on LI offering the walkable urban feel of a big city. Nestled along Hempstead Harbor on the Gold Coast of Long Island, Roslyn Landing is a townhome and condo community with the feel of a small town and shopping and restaurants within walking distance.

This gated community in Nassau County features many home options including single-family homes, three- and two-story townhomes, and flat-over-flat condos that complement the historic architecture of the village. It’s set on 12 acres of landscaped grounds right next to the entertainment, dining, and shops in Roslyn. Step outside your home and stroll along the waterfront promenade or enjoy the community’s other amenities like the modern fitness center with Peloton bikes, a dog run, two ponds, and a Club House with a kid’s area, billiards, and catering kitchen.

3-bedroom homes in the Roslyn Landing community are priced at $1.7 million and up.

Country Pointe Meadows – New Gated Community in Nassau County with Resort-Style Living

  • Housing options: Townhomes, villa homes & garden homes
  • Location: Yaphank, Town of Brookhaven

Country Pointe Meadows is one of the top gated communities on Long Island for new construction and resort living. The development is backed by acres of parkland with a 100’ natural buffer on the other side and greenbelt trails. This exciting community is made up of clusters of homes around several lakes with many home options to fit your lifestyle and budget.

Country Pointe Meadows offers resort-style amenities for residents including a pool deck with two heated pools, cabanas, and the Poolside Bar & Lounge. Hang out with friends, watch the game on the large screens, and enjoy cocktails – all in your own backyard. There are pickleball, tennis, and bocce courts plus a gym with fitness classes, sauna and steam room to keep active. The newest addition is The Boulevard, a convenient shopping center with shops and restaurants.

Townhomes in the community start in the high $700s with garden homes starting in the $600s.

Stone Hill at Muttontown – Custom Homes in a European-Influenced Nassau County Gated Community

  • Housing options: Existing homes and new custom homes built on remaining lots
  • Location: Muttontown, Town of Oyster Bay

Stone Hill is one of the most desirable gated communities in Long Island. This European-style gated community features 80 estate home sites over 148 acres of mature trees and manicured grounds. Residents enjoy privacy, space, and the security of 24-hour manned gated entry plus use of the clubhouse with an indoor swimming pool, tennis courts, and a fitness center.

Stone Hill at Muttontown is a great place to live for families and located in the Syosset School District, one of the best Long Island school districts. It’s served by Thompson Middle School and Syosset High School, a Blue Ribbon school with 99% of graduates pursuing higher education.

Along with occasional existing homes that go on the market, there are a limited number of lots available in the Stone Hill Estates section. Kirby Hill, the community developer, works with some of the best luxury home builders on Long Island to build new homes in Stone Hill. Remaining home sites are 1 to 2.5-acre lots that can accommodate horse barns, private pools, and more.

The Hamlet in Jericho – One of the Best Gated Communities in Long Island for Maintenance-Free Condo Living

  • Housing options: Townhomes
  • Location: Jericho, Town of Oyster Bay

The Hamlet is a luxury gated condo community of 386 condos/townhomes on the 89-acre former Lehman Estate. The Hamlet is a popular Long Island neighborhood for families with two wooded walking trails, a playground, an updated fitness center, tennis courts, heated pools, and a kiddie pool. The community clubhouse is the perfect gathering spot with a TV lounge, card rooms, library, and party room. This gated community is in the desirable A-rated Jericho School District.

Built in 1982, the Jericho community is divided into three sections with 10 models ranging from 2,000 to more than 3,000 square feet. Most townhomes are 3-bedroom with 3 bathrooms and two-car garages, but there are larger and smaller units. Most homes for sale in the Hamlet in Jericho sell in the mid $700s to high $800s. The Hamlet is served by the Picket Farm HOA with HOA fees ranging from $600 to $1,000 per month.

Gated Communities in Suffolk County Long Island

Suffolk County, Long Island gated communities run the gamut from peaceful, rural communities surrounded by nature to luxurious waterfront homes with new construction. Here are the best communities to explore in Suffolk County.

The Colony in Holbrook – Private Long Island Gated Community with Close-Knit Community & Great Location

  • Housing options: Townhomes and single-family homes
  • Location: Holbrook, Town of Islip

The Colony in Holbrook is a large gated community in Holbrook with detached and attached homes built in 1990. The family-friendly community is just off the Long Island Expressway yet offers a quiet setting with private, tree-lined streets. The Colony features a gatehouse entrance with a 15,000 square foot two-story clubhouse with a fully equipped gym, game and card rooms, racquetball courts, lounge, and ballroom.

The Colony offers great amenities including three swimming pools, a playground, lighted tennis courts, shuffleboard, bocce ball, and basketball. You’ll enjoy a sense of community and plenty of events for residents including kid’s and adult holiday parties and a book club.

Spacious townhomes feature 2,000 to 3,000 square feet of living space with 2-car garages. Townhomes usually sell in the high $500s to $700s. The Colony in Holbrook HOA fees are around $500/month.

Ranches at Eastport – One of the Best Gated Communities in Long Island NY with Custom New Homes & Affordable Lakeside Living

  • Housing options: Custom new homes
  • Location: Eastport, Town of Brookhaven

Located in the Town of Brookhaven section of Eastport is the Ranches at Eastport, a desirable South Shore Long Island gated community. The development offers new construction homes customized to your needs with many floor plans that feature 11-foot ceilings, wood floors, custom tile, and more. All homes have two-car garages with side entry and a full basement. Select lots have the option to add a pool.

Ranches at Eastport boasts low taxes starting at $4,375 per year in true taxes for primary residences. That’s a steal compared to the median Suffolk County property tax bill of almost $9,500! The community also boasts modest HOA fees that include water, garbage removal, yard maintenance, snow removal, and amenities like the heated pool, tennis and bocce ball, fitness center, and clubhouse.

Country Woods at the Colony Preserve – The Only Attainably Priced Single-Family New Home Community in Suffolk County

  • Housing options: Ranch and two-story homes
  • Location: Shirley, Town of Brookhaven

Country Woods at the Colony Preserve is one of the most anticipated gated communities in Suffolk County NY. Located in the hamlet of Shirley on the South Shore, the development is right off William Floyd Parkway next to the Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge. You’ll love living at the gateway to the east end with the perfect blend of unspoiled nature and peace and nearby amenities. Protected Long Island beaches and marinas are less than two miles away!

The gated community bills itself as Suffolk County’s only attainably priced single-family new construction community. The 205-acre development has 99 acres dedicated to the town for future parkland use with two distinct communities: The Manor, an active adult condo community, and Country Woods, a gated community of two-story and ranch style homes.

There are 74 single-family homes in the community, each on a quarter-acre lot situated around a large lake. Most homes back onto pristine open space. There are six home plans to choose from, each with a garage and a covered porch and/or patio. New homes for sale start in the mid-$300s.

Three Village Green –Wooded Long Island Gated Community in a Great School District

  • Housing options: Single-family homes
  • Location: South Setauket, Town of Brookhaven

Three Village Green is a desirable gated community in Long Island on the North Shore. This South Setauket community of 83 units is an HOA community that offers low-maintenance living in the highly rated Three Village School District. It’s just a mile away from the Smithaven Mall and five minutes from Stony Brook Hospital and University!

All five home models have more than 2,000 square feet of space with attached garages and full basements. Community amenities include a fitness center, basketball court, playground, and saltwater swimming pool. Your HOA fees include weekly mowing, periodic flowerbed weeding and fertilization, sprinkler maintenance, roof maintenance and repairs, gutter cleaning, driveway sealing, snow removal, water, and garbage pickup.

Long Island Gated Communities Map

Have you found a gated community in Long Island calling your name? Give us a call at Zippboxx for a free, personalized moving estimate so we can help you get settled in and enjoying the good life without the moving day stress.

Rob Marchese
Rob Marchese is one of the founders of Zippboxx Moving and Storage. Since the start of the company it's been Rob's mission to change the way the moving industry is perceived.  The number one goal is to make the moving and storage process as stress free as possible for each and every customer. "The way we do this is by honesty, transparency, and providing a high quality of service."
  • Request a Quote

    • MM slash DD slash YYYY
  • Popular Categories

  • Popular Tags