Top Long Island Neighborhoods | Best Places to Live on Long Island

It’s no secret that the island has a lot to offer, from its rich history and abundance of cultural attractions to its beautiful beaches and parks. But with so many different neighborhoods to choose from, how do you know which one is right for you?

Here are a few things to consider when choosing a neighborhood on Long Island:

  1. What are your priorities? Are you looking for a safe community or one with good schools? 
  2. What’s your budget? Long Island is home to a wide range of neighborhoods, from affluent enclaves to more modestly priced communities. 
  3. What’s your lifestyle? Do you prefer a quiet suburban lifestyle, or are you looking for something more urban? 

Massapequa – Most Diverse & Great for Families

If you’re looking for a suburban oasis on Long Island, look no further than Massapequa. This hamlet is located in the town of Oyster Bay. 

Families make up a large portion of the population, as do young professionals and retirees. The community is quite diverse, with people from all walks of life enjoying the suburban lifestyle. 

Is Massapequa safe? Yes, the crime rate is quite low. In fact, it is 45% lower than the national average. 

There is a mix of single-family homes, townhouses, and condos available. You’re sure to find something that suits your needs. When in Long Island, Massapequa is known throughout Long Island for its restaurant “All American Burger”.

The community is close-knit and friendly. There’s a strong sense of pride among residents. Many people enjoy spending time outdoors, whether it’s taking a walk in the park or having a picnic at the beach. Famous people hailing from Massapequa are the Baldwin brothers, including Alec Baldwin who finished high school here.

Plainview – Perfect for Families

This lovely neighborhood has plenty to offer residents, from a safe and family-friendly environment to beautiful homes and a thriving real estate market.

Plainview is known for its farming and agriculture community. They are famous for growing cucumbers for Heinz pickle factories. The area is also safe and peaceful, perfect for those who are looking for a quiet place to call home. And with plenty of green space and parks, there’s no shortage of things to do in this lovely community.

Commack – Best for Athletes

Commack is a neighborhood in the town of Huntington, in Suffolk County, Long Island. It’s a great place for athletes, with plenty of open space and amenities like public parks and sports facilities being known for then-sports facility, Long Island Arena. The real estate market is strong, and there are a variety of homes available to suit any budget. The community is safe and welcoming, and there are plenty of things to do in the area. 

Huntington – Largest in Suffolk

Huntington is one of the most popular suburbs on Long Island. It’s large size and central location make it a desirable place to live for many families. The real estate market in Huntington is very strong, with homes selling quickly and for top dollar. The neighborhood is safe and family-friendly, with plenty of things to do and see. Huntington is home to many beautiful homes, ranging from historic mansions to modern condos—Oheka Castle, Heckscher Park, Walt Whitman’s Birthplace, sunset at Centerport Harbor, the historic former Huntington Sewing & Trade School, the Heckscher Museum of Art.

Islip – Safest and Slow Paced Haven on Long Island

When it comes to real estate, the Islip neighborhood in Long Island is a hidden gem. This quaint community has a lot to offer residents, from its charming homes to its safe and welcoming atmosphere. If you’re thinking about moving to Islip, here’s what you need to know about this wonderful neighborhood.

Islip is a great place to call home for a number of reasons. First, the homes in this community are absolutely beautiful. From historic colonials to charming Cape Cod Recreation Center, there’s something for everyone in Islip. Plus, the prices are very reasonable compared to other areas on Long Island.

Another big selling point for Islip is its safety. This is a very family-friendly neighborhood, and crime is very low. In fact, it’s one of the safest neighborhoods on Long Island.

Smithtown – “Main Street America”

Smithtown is a neighborhood in Long Island belonging to Suffolk County. It’s a beautiful place to live, with a strong real estate market and plenty of things to do boasting an impressive array of parks, state parks and beautiful beaches including Short Beach, Long Beach, King’s Buff and Callahan’s Beach.

The people who live here are friendly and welcoming, and the community is safe and well-kept. Homes in Smithtown are varied, but all of them have a certain charm that makes this neighborhood so special. 

Valley Stream – Most Commuter-Friendly & Close to Queens

Valley Stream is a neighborhood in Long Island that is commuter friendly as it borders Queens. 

With a strong real estate market, it was hailed as ”the best place to live in New York” for 2017 by Money Magazine.

The neighborhood is safe and has a variety of different types of homes. It is a great place to live for those who enjoy being close to nature and the big city. 

Merrick – South Shore Lifestyle

The Merrick neighborhood in Long Island is a great place to live for many reasons. The real estate market is strong, and there are plenty of homes to choose from. The community is close-knit and friendly, and there is always something to do. The area is also very safe, making it a great choice for families. Merrick is also the hometown of actress, Lindsay Lohan and the makers of the world-famous ice cream brand Ben and Jerry.

Stony Brook – College Town

Looking for a college town with a great real estate market? Stony Brook might be the perfect place for you. This Long Island neighborhood is known for its vibrant atmosphere and diverse community as it is home to the known Stony Brook University which ranks 25th among public universities awarded by the prestigious Wall Street Journal/Times Higher Education U.S. College Rankings for 2020. 

Roslyn Village – Most Affluent Neighborhood

Roslyn Village is a historic town on Long Island’s Gold Coast with a thriving real estate market. The neighborhood is known for its beautiful homes, safe streets, and vibrant community—its East Hills area garnering a spot in Bloomberg’s rankings among one of the Top 50 richest places. Residents enjoy the town’s many shops and restaurants, as well as its proximity to New York City. Roslyn Village is the perfect place to call home for families and young professionals alike.

Ronkonkoma – First Road by Vanderbilt Motor Parkway

Ronkonkoma in Suffolk County in Long Island is a great place to live for a variety of reasons. The area has a rich history dating back to the 1600s, when it was first settled by English colonists. 

The area is also famous for its namesake Lake Ronkonkoma which is an original ancestral home of many native Indian tribes. It is also known for the first road built for automobiles carried out by Vanderbilt Motor Parkway.

The real estate market in Ronkonkoma is very strong, with homes appreciating at a healthy rate. The neighborhood is also very safe, with low crime rates and a strong sense of community. There are plenty of things to do in Ronkonkoma, from enjoying nature among many fun activities.

Best Places to Live on Long Island Map

If you’re looking for a great place to live with a good quality of life, look no further than Long Island. There are many wonderful neighborhoods to choose from, and each has its own unique charm. After deciding which Long Island neighborhood is right for you, Zippboxx can help make your relocation smooth and stress-free.

Rob Marchese
Rob Marchese is one of the founders of Zippboxx Moving and Storage. Since the start of the company it's been Rob's mission to change the way the moving industry is perceived.  The number one goal is to make the moving and storage process as stress free as possible for each and every customer. "The way we do this is by honesty, transparency, and providing a high quality of service."
  • Request a Quote

    • MM slash DD slash YYYY
  • Popular Categories

  • Popular Tags